Hay prices in Pennsylvania

Name: Hay prices in Pennsylvania
Creator: BaleWise

44 listings · updated September 9, 2026

~120 mi~120 miLarge square400 lbTimothy1st cutDeliverslarge bale, ~400 lb stated · 2026 grass/timothy horse hay, "made dry, made young, no dust, no mold" · delivery with 10-bale minimum · reply with phone + ZIPchecked Sep 6$125/bale

Airville, PA · ~113 mi~113 miSmall squareMix1st cutsmall square · 2026 1st cut mixed grass, field-cured, "no rain, no herbicides or pesticides" · 50+ bales $4.75, 100+ $4.50 · unload 100 bales into the haymow, get 10 free · buyer loads at barn, cash · calls only, Mon–Satchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~152 mi~152 miSmall square1st cutsquare · 1st cut, "no mold or mud" · calls only — seller won't answer texts or emailchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~142 mi~142 miSmall squareAlfalfa1st cutsquare · 1st cut 2026, "horse quality" — rye grass, wild alfalfa and clover · cash and carry, pick up at barn · also posted as Waverly on the Poconos boardchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~43 mi~43 miSmall squareTimothy2nd cutsmall square · 2nd cut timothy, fertilized, listed at 101 RFV · about 750 bales available, quantity pricing offered · Indiana County · contact through AllHaychecked Aug 30$8.00/bale

~88 mi~88 miRound4×52nd cut4×5 round · 2nd cut 2026, "good nice soft hay," rain-free, baled last week · weight not statedchecked Sep 6$100/balePriced high

~102 mi~102 miLarge square3×3×71st cut3×3×7 large square, weight not stated · 1st cutting grass hay, baled dry · ~30 bales availablechecked Sep 6$120/bale

~91 mi~91 mi1st cutbale type not listed · 1st cut made end of May 2026, "dust and spray free"checked Sep 6$8.00/bale

~110 mi~110 miRound4×41st cutDelivers4×4 round, weight not stated · 2026 first cut, kept dry · Beaver County · delivers 10 bales at a timechecked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price

~166 mi~166 miSmall square2-stringtwo-string kicker bale, weight not stated · meadow grass · pickup near Dublin, PA · cash only, buyer loadschecked Sep 6$5.00/baleFair price

~118 mi~118 miRound4×4OrchardTimothy4×4 round, weight not stated · timothy, orchard grass and clover, baled June and July 2026, never rained on but stored outside now · 100 available · cut not stated · Erie Countychecked Sep 6$45.00/baleGood deal

~106 mi~106 miRound4×51st cut4×5 round, weight not stated · 2026 first cut round bales, stored inside, located near Canonsburgchecked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price

~102 mi~102 miSmall squareOrchard1st cutsmall square, weight not stated · 1st cutting orchard grass horse hay, baled dry · ad’s price field says $6; the ad text says $5.50 a bale, which is the figure boarded · Lancaster Countychecked Sep 6$5.50/bale

~73 mi~73 miMix1st cutDeliversbale type not listed · 2026 1st cutting mixed grass, made June 3, stored inside · seller notes the bales are light because the hay is very dry, with no mold · $8 at the barn, any quantity · delivery on gooseneck loads of 100+ bales within 10 miles of Waynesboro, fee applies · Franklin Countychecked Sep 6$8.00/bale

~118 mi~118 miLarge squareMix2nd cutDeliverslarge square · 2026 second-cutting grass mix the seller calls beautiful and soft, made dry, in large bales given as roughly 425 to 450 lb — a range rather than a stated weight. Suited to sheep, goats and horses, and delivery is availablechecked Sep 6$130/bale

~119 mi~119 miSmall square40 lbAlfalfaMix1st cutDeliverssquare · first-cutting grass and alfalfa mix in small bales of about 40 lb, which the seller calls horse quality and made right. Fifteen-bale minimum for pickup, and delivery is availablechecked Sep 6$10.00/balePriced high

~65 mi~65 miSmall squareTimothyMixDeliverssmall square, weight not stated — the seller gives a range, "approximately weight between 40 and 50 lb each" · timothy and orchard grass mix, good for horses, hay rides or other livestock, over 100 to sell · the same seller also lists 4′×5′ timothy/orchard rounds at $70 · delivery $5.00 a loaded mile · cut not statedchecked Sep 6$7.00/bale

~86 mi~86 miGrass1st cutbale type not stated, weight not stated · first crop mostly grass hay on wagons, made around June 1, 800 bales availablechecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~122 mi~122 miSmall squareGrass1st cutfirst-cut square bales of brome grass, fescue and clover; 500 available, $4.50 a bale if you buy 100 or morechecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~128 mi~128 miMixbale not listed · good mixed hay, no rainchecked Sep 6$3.50/bale

~122 mi~122 miRound1st cutDeliversround, weight not stated · 1st crop round bales the seller describes as good heifer and beef hay; about 30 bales inside and 10 outside · will deliver 2-3 at a time for a small feechecked Sep 6$25.00/bale

~130 mi~130 mi1st cutbale not listed · good quality first cutting hay grown with Mycorrplus, 16 bales totalchecked Sep 6$50.00/bale

~53 mi~53 miSmall squareMixsquare, weight not stated · just-made mixed grass hay with some red clover, third cutting, small square bales; pickup on farm, ZIP 17049checked Sep 6$7.00/bale

~70 mi~70 miRound4×5OrchardMix1st cut4×5 round, weight not stated · orchard grass mixed hay, 1st cut, net wrapped, good dry hay; the ad says "approx. 700-800 lbs. per. bale", a range, so no single weight is recorded · picked up at barn, cash onlychecked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price

~65 mi~65 miRound4×5TimothyMixDelivers4×5 round, weight not stated · timothy and orchard grass mix, over 100 bales, barn kept, no weeds, can be fed to horses; will load trailer or truck · delivery available at $5.00 a loaded mile one waychecked Sep 6$70.00/balePriced high

~92 mi~92 miSmall square2nd cutsquare, weight not stated · 2nd cut square baleschecked Sep 6$6.00/bale

~93 mi~93 miSmall squareMix2nd cutsquare, weight not stated · 2nd cut mixed grass square bales, off the wagonchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale

~82 mi~82 miSmall square1st cutsquare, weight not stated · 150 of this year’s first cut square bales at $6.00; the seller also has about 30 bales from last year at $5.00checked Sep 6$6.00/bale

~11 mi~11 miOrchardMixDeliversbale not listed · orchard grass mix with some timothy, and some foxtail; the seller states the bales were dry when baled but got rained on afterwards and are stored outside, and describes it as great cow hay · delivery available at additional cost depending on distancechecked Sep 6$40.00/bale

~44 mi~44 mi2nd cutDeliversbale not listed · the ad offers "Horse Hay: Good Quality 2nd Crop" at $6.00 a bale; the same farm also sells small square straw, bagged ear corn, shelled corn and corn stalk bundles · pick-up at the farm in Windber (Paint Twp) or delivery for a fee · the ad gives the location as 147 Spruce Run Road near Rt. 601checked Sep 9$6.00/bale

~43 mi~43 miSmall squareGrassDeliverssmall square, weight not stated · "nice, good quality grass hay"; the seller has first, second and third cuttings from this year and a couple hundred bales available · the $5 price is not tied to a particular cutting · delivery for a feechecked Sep 9$5.00/bale

~108 mi~108 miSmall squareMixsquare, weight not stated · freshly cut 3rd cutting square bales, described as horse hay, pasture mix · 100 bales availablechecked Sep 9$8.00/bale

~112 mi~112 miRoundMix2nd cutDeliversround, weight not stated · 18 round bales of 2nd cut hay, described as horse hay, pasture mix · $50 a bale picked up, $60 a bale delivered "within reasonable miles"checked Sep 9$50.00/bale

~102 mi~102 miRound4×54×5 round · 2026 crop 4x5 round bales at $35, plastic twine tied and stored outside, 150+ available; the seller also lists about 60 of the 2025 4x5 bales at $25 · the seller can load · cutting not statedchecked Sep 9$35.00/baleGood deal

~91 mi~91 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyMixsquare, weight not stated · 3rd cut squares, "good soft hay" — a timothy, orchard and alfalfa mix, spray freechecked Sep 9$10.00/bale

Call for price

Sellers who publish everything but the number. Their phone or listing is one tap away.

~53 mi~53 miSmall square1st cut small squares + 4×4 rounds, 2nd cut small squares (prices by phone) · Snyder Countychecked Sep 9callCall 845-258-8569

~104 mi~104 miSmall squareOrchardTimothyDeliversOrchard/timothy small squares and 4×5 rounds — the AllHay listing says 3,500 bales, fertilized, a little clover; the priced Craigslist ad expired, so call or text for current pricing · pickup or delivery · Washington Countychecked Aug 30callCall 724-350-9137

Perryopolis, PA · ~91 mi~91 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyDeliversSmall squares, big squares, rounds + 21-bale bundles, 1st and 2nd cut, orchard/timothy/alfalfa (prices by text) · year-round supply · pickup Vanderbilt or Greensburg, shipping availablechecked Jul 17callCall 724-323-3762

Russell, PA · ~98 mi~98 miSmall squareOrchardTimothyOrchard/timothy small squares, 4×4 and 4×5 rounds, wrapped baleage, rye straw (prices by phone) · mostly pre-order — field pickup in summer, barn pickup by appointment · Warren Countychecked Jul 17callCall 814-757-8245

Gap, PA · ~126 mi~126 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyDeliversOrchard/timothy blend, alfalfa, compressed bales — sourced from Lancaster County farms (prices by phone) · delivery for a fee · Mon–Fri 7–5, Sat by appointmentchecked Jul 17callCall 717-371-1202

Germansville, PA · ~132 mi~132 miSmall squareAlfalfaTimothyLarge-scale hay grower/dealer, exporting since 1974 — timothy, alfalfa, horse hay, low-sugar and 35 lb compressed bales plus 3×4×8 field bales (prices by phone) · farm store pickup · Lehigh Countychecked Jul 17callCall 610-767-2409

~81 mi~81 miSmall squareDelivers2026 fresh first-cut square bale hay; the seller ("call Eugene") states no price in the current ad. Barn kept and always dry, with delivery within 15 miles of Chicora and a 30-bale minimum, per his earlier ad.checked Sep 9callView listing ↗

~52 mi~52 miSmall squareSecond-cutting small square bales — the seller asks buyers to call for the amount available and the pricechecked Sep 9callCall 845-258-8569

~93 mi~93 miSmall squareOrchardMixDeliversSmall square bales of orchard grass, orchard grass mix and mixed grass hay, by the bale or in bundles of 21; delivery available, call for price. (The same seller also sells wheat and barley straw.)checked Sep 9callView listing ↗

Selling hay? Listing is free. Buyers here are already looking.List your hay ›

Price moves in Pennsylvania: 2 in the last 8 weeks

Private seller$140 → $130Sep 5
Private seller$2 → $4Jul 18

Same listing, different price between our checks; nothing else counts as a move.

What hay costs in Pennsylvania

BaleWise tracks 44 hay listings in Pennsylvania, 35 with listed prices, checked September 9, 2026. Every price is the seller’s own, per bale, next to the size of bale it buys. Nothing is converted, estimated, or averaged into a number the seller never quoted.

4×5-and-under rounds run $35.00 to $100 a bale across prices from 7 sellers, with a midpoint of $50.00.

Verdicts on the board above compare a listing against other Mid-Atlantic listings of the same bale size, at least 6 of them, or we don’t rate it at all. It is the same yardstick the region board uses, so a listing carries the same verdict on either page.

This board shows Pennsylvania only. Buying near a state line? The full Mid-Atlantic board includes sellers just over it.