Hay prices in New York
Covering New York. Search any ZIP for true distances from you.
Type
Cut
Form
Size
Delivery
Stamford, NY · ~56 mi~56 miSmall square1st cutsquare · 1st cut, "organically grown, no chemicals or preservatives" · $8.50/bale off the wagon, 20-bale minimum, discounts at 150+ · pickup by appointment, cash · willowviewhillfarm.com · cross-posted on six NY boardschecked Sep 6$10.00/bale
~60 mi~60 miSmall square45 lbOrchardTimothyMix1st cutsmall square, 45 lb · 1st cut 2026, "organically raised" timothy/orchard/trefoil/clover mix · 40 bales · text first, pickup at the farmchecked Sep 6$3.50/baleGood deal
~105 mi~105 miSmall squareGrassMix1st cutsmall square, 40–45 lb stated · 1st cut timothy/orchard/clover mix · 1,000 bales · pickup · contact through the AllHay listingchecked Aug 30$6.00/bale
~31 mi~31 miSmall square1st cutDeliversbale size not stated — small square assumed · "stored dry" · cut not stated · pickup or deliverychecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~71 mi~71 miRound4×51st cut4×5 round, weight not stated · "fresh cut 2026" · calls only, seller won't answer email · cross-posted on three NY boardschecked Sep 6$25.00/baleGood deal
Chateaugay, NY · ~161 mi~161 miSmall square1st cutsmall square · self-service barn at 38 Lake St — open 24/7, solar lights, load yourself · 1st cut $4, mulch $2, wrapped 2nd-cut baleage $50 per 4-ft roundchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~167 mi~167 miSmall square1st cutsmall square · 2025 crop, "excellent quality," all livestock · $3–4 by quantity · cut not stated · same Parker Rd seller as the $40 round-bale rowchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~167 mi~167 miRound1st cutround, weight not stated · 2025 crop 1st cut (2nd-cut grass also $40, some 1st cut $25–30), "no rain and stored inside" · same Parker Rd seller as the $4 square rowchecked Sep 6$40.00/bale
Earlville, NY · ~7 mi~7 miSmall square43 lbGrass1st cutDeliversEarlville hay dealer; their retail store HAYNOW.COM sells "Timothy Orchard Grass Hay, 1st Cutting" (2026 crop) at $16.25 a bale — "Each timothy orchard bale is 43lbs. on average." Sold in 18-bale shrink-wrapped pallets, "Grown on our Upstate NY Farms - based in Earlville, New York." Price includes delivery and forklift stacking in a ground-level storage area; 2nd cut is listed at $19.00. Volume discounts from 18 bales up to 180.checked Aug 30$16.25/balePriced high
Goshen, NY · ~117 mi~117 miSmall squareTimothy1st cutDeliverssquare · 1st cut timothy grass $7 (organic 1st cut also $7), 2nd cut timothy $9, mulch $5 · price list on the farm site · local delivery for 10–100 bales at $60/hr round-trip drive time plus load/unload, or pick up at the farm · Orange County, lower Hudson Valleychecked Aug 30$7.00/bale
Hillsdale, NY · ~111 mi~111 miRound1st cutround bale, 1st cut · weight not stated · ordered through the farm's website · Columbia County, lower Hudson Valley / Berkshire edgechecked Aug 30$40.00/bale
~58 mi~58 miRound4×5Mix1st cut4×5 round, weight not stated · 1st cut hay/grass mix for horses and cattle, stored inside · 3×3×7 large squares also offered at $65 · quantity discountschecked Sep 6$55.00/baleFair price
~111 mi~111 miRound4×41st cutDelivers4×4 round, weight not stated · 1st cutting, covered · 4×5 rounds also offered at $50 · local delivery availablechecked Sep 6$40.00/baleGood deal
Central Square, NY · ~47 mi~47 miMixbale type not listed · 2026 June-cut mixed grass hay, no rain · picked up only (ad posted from Pennellville; seller address is Central Square)checked Sep 6$5.00/bale
~168 mi~168 miSmall square1st cutDeliverssmall square, weight not stated · 1st cutting · local delivery available · quantity discountchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~89 mi~89 miLarge square3×3×7OrchardTimothy1st cut3×3×7 large square, 550–600 lb · 1st cut orchard grass/timothy · located near Bethel Woods (ad posted from Jeffersonville)checked Sep 6$50.00/bale
Fort Ann, NY · ~111 mi~111 miRound1st cutDeliversround, weight not stated · first cut round bales stored inside; the same ad also lists first cut squares at $6 and second cut squares at $7 · delivery possible for a feechecked Sep 6$55.00/bale
~150 mi~150 miRound1st cutround, size and weight not stated · 1st cut, sold out of the fieldchecked Sep 6$40.00/bale
~50 mi~50 miSmall squareMixDeliverssmall square, weight not stated · mixed grasses, no sprays or fertilizers, ten years organically raised · no rain, stored inside · seller suggests it for beef cattle, sheep, goats and rabbits · cut not stated · cash at the barn; will deliver for gas moneychecked Sep 6$3.00/bale
~107 mi~107 miSmall squareOrchardTimothy1st cutsquare, weight not stated · 1st cutting orchard grass and timothy with some clover; the ad states "40-45 lb bales", a range, so no single weight is recorded · $6 each at the barnchecked Sep 6$6.00/bale
~74 mi~74 miSmall squareMix1st cutsquare, weight not stated · small squares, mixed grasses, no sprays or fertilizers, in the barn ready for pickup; seller states they cannot deliverchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~79 mi~79 miSmall squareOrchardTimothyMix1st cutsmall square, 40–45 lb · 2026 1st cut timothy, brome and orchard grass mix, called horse quality · cash at the barn in Rotterdam (ad posted from Schenectady)checked Sep 6$6.00/bale
~134 mi~134 miSmall square45 lbMix1st cutsquare, 45 lb average · 2026 1st cutting, nice mix of grass, tight heavy bales, no rain, dry in the barn · 10-bale minimum · St. Lawrence Countychecked Sep 6$6.00/baleFair price
~32 mi~32 mi1st cutbale type not listed · this year’s early 1st cutting · 800 bales available · ad’s price field says $5; the ad text says $4.50 a bale, which is the figure boardedchecked Sep 6$4.50/bale
~108 mi~108 miRound4×51st cut4×5 round, weight not stated · net wrapped, described as very nice early 1st cut · call for info · Dutchess Countychecked Sep 6$60.00/balePriced high
Nichols, NY · ~70 mi~70 miSmall squareGrassMix1st cut"1st Cutting small square bales Mixed Grass,clover mix. Different poundage’s for everyone’s need! 30-50lb bales and plenty of 50-70 lb bales. Asking $6/bale, $5 for the lighter bales." Organic, non-GMO, no pesticides; 2nd cut expected. Bale weight is given only as ranges, so no single weight is recorded.checked Aug 30$6.00/bale
Newfield, NY · ~65 mi~65 midetails in notes"Organic Clover Wrapped Balage. Dry Matter 34.7, Average Weight #1538 (#520 DM) CP 16.9 TDN 59.2 RFQ 163, Milk Per ton 2920, NEL .60 Approx. 200 available; Asking $80." A second lot is listed at "Dry Matter 29.6 Average Weight #1650 (#488 DM) ... Approx 160 Available, Asking $100 or make offer." Bale shape is not stated. The seller also offers straw, which is not part of this listing.checked Aug 30$80.00/bale
Prattsburgh, NY · ~92 mi~92 miSmall square1st cutDelivers"We sell quality small square hay bales in the western Finger Lakes region of New York state." Horse quality first cutting baled in June-July, "$4.40 picked up"; cattle quality baled in August is $3.30 picked up. "Small square bales about 40-45 lbs each" — a range, so no single weight is recorded. Delivery has a 25-bale minimum to Yates, Ontario, Livingston, northern Steuben and Schuyler counties. Second cutting listed as coming soon.checked Aug 30$4.40/bale
~81 mi~81 mi45 lbbale type not stated, at a stated 45 lb (the ad says "45# bails") · last year’s hay, kept dry and well stored, about 75 bales · cut not statedchecked Sep 6$3.00/bale
~50 mi~50 miSmall squareGrassMixDeliverssmall square, weight not stated · mixed grasses, stored inside, no sprays or fertilizers, ten years organically raised, no rain and never wet · $3.00 a bale cash at the barn; will deliver for additional gas money · cut not statedchecked Sep 6$3.00/bale
~90 mi~90 miSmall square50 lbTimothyDeliverssmall square, at a stated 50 lb (the ad is titled "50# Timothy Square Bales") · from field to barn, never wet · $5 picked up or $6 a bale delivered, ten-bale minimum · cut not statedchecked Sep 6$4.00/baleGood deal
~217 mi~217 miRound4×4GrassMix4×4 round, weight not stated · 2026 first and second crop, tedded, baled dry and wrapped in plastic · timothy, tall fescue and orchard grass mix · cut not stated (seller has both)checked Sep 6$35.00/baleGood deal
~87 mi~87 miRound4×4Delivers4×4 round, weight not stated · this season’s hay, at 440 Brownell Road · delivery available · cut not statedchecked Sep 6$45.00/baleGood deal
~148 mi~148 miRoundTimothyMix1st cut2026 first-cutting round bales, baled the end of June, mostly timothy with mixed grass, never rained on; pickup only — the seller states he cannot deliver at this timechecked Sep 6$40.00/bale
~155 mi~155 miSmall squareTimothysquare bales just cut, "has timothy in it"; 40 left at the time of the adchecked Sep 6$3.00/bale
~121 mi~121 miTimothyMix1st cutlate first cut from June 26 2026 — timothy, orchard grass and mixed grasses; the seller calls it good quality but "slightly drier than it should be due to the later cutting". Second-cut hay with some weeds also offered at $4. Can load an open truck or trailerchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale
~70 mi~70 miRound4×4Grasssecond and third cutting grass round bales, stated by the seller as 4 ft × 4½ ftchecked Sep 6$45.00/baleGood deal
~32 mi~32 mi2nd cutsecond cutting, 200 bales available; the $6 comes from the ad’s price field — the ad text itself states no pricechecked Sep 6$6.00/bale
~107 mi~107 miSmall squareOrchard2nd cut2026 second cutting orchard grass and timothy with some clover; the seller states "40-45 lb bales", a range rather than a single weight, so none is recorded. $6 each at the barnchecked Sep 6$7.00/bale
Berkshire, NY · ~50 mi~50 miSmall squareGrassMix1st cutDeliverssmall square · mixed grass hay, 1st cut $5/bale · same farm lists 2nd cut small squares at $6, 3×3×7 large squares at $60 and 4×5 rounds at $35 · ships throughout the East Coast · Southern Tier, between Binghamton and Ithaca · weight not statedchecked Aug 30$5.00/bale
~103 mi~103 miSmall squareTimothyMix1st cutsquare, weight not stated · 1st cut timothy mix, stored in barn; the ad says "35-40lb bales", a range, so no single weight is recorded · bulk discount over 100 baleschecked Sep 6$6.50/bale
Jordanville, NY · ~30 mi~30 mi1st cutbale not listed · this year’s first cut, a couple hundred bales, buy one or take allchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~54 mi~54 miRound4×41st cut4×4 round, weight not stated · dry round bales, never rained on, stored inside since baling, net wrapped; this is the late-June first cutting (has some weeds) — the ad also lists May/early-June 1st cut at $55 and 2nd cut at $65checked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price
~18 mi~18 miSmall square1st cutDeliverssquare, weight not stated · first cut small square hay, no rainchecked Sep 6$4.00/bale
~12 mi~12 miSmall square40 lb2nd cutsquare, at a stated 40 lb · 2nd cut square bales, pickup the same day they are baled, Sunday and Monday only; the ad notes the price goes up once they are in the barnchecked Sep 6$4.00/baleGood deal
~40 mi~40 miRound4×4Timothy4×4 round, weight not stated · approximately 120 net-wrapped soft-core bales, never rained on before baling; the seller describes it as fully mature stemmy mostly timothy grass hay with some broadleaf weeds — OK for beef, not dairy or horse hay · not selling a few bales at a timechecked Sep 6$14.00/baleGood deal
~49 mi~49 miRound5×55×5 round, weighing approximately 800 lb as stated · 2026 new-seeding round bales, stored outsidechecked Sep 6$20.00/bale
~154 mi~154 miSmall squareMix1st cutsquare, weight not stated · square baled 1st cutting, no rain, mixed grasses, well packed bales; $5 at the barn, 3454 Bakerstand Rdchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale
~96 mi~96 miRound5×55×5 round, weight not stated · twelve hard-core round bales, baled last August and under cover since; good hay with no dust, located near Star Lakechecked Sep 6$10.00/bale
~78 mi~78 mi2nd cutbale not listed · second cutting grass hay, no rain and no dustchecked Sep 6$5.00/bale
~111 mi~111 miRound4×42nd cutDelivers4×4 round, weight not stated · 2nd cutting round bales, order now and take them as they are baled; the same seller also lists first cutting starting at $30 · delivery availablechecked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price
Call for price
Sellers who publish everything but the number. Their phone or listing is one tap away.
North Collins, NY · ~174 mi~174 miSmall squareOrchardTimothyDeliversTimothy and orchard grass, small bales and compressed bundles (current price menu posted on their Facebook page) · year-round retail hay supplier for western NYchecked Jul 5callCall 716-432-2715
Pawling, NY · ~133 mi~133 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyMixDeliversHay dealer for 100+ years — western and NY alfalfa, timothy, orchard grass and mixes, round and square bales (prices by phone) · delivers the tri-state area · Mon–Fri 8–4, Sat 9–3 · Dutchess Countychecked Jul 17callCall 845-855-3291
Camillus, NY · ~41 mi~41 miSmall squareAlfalfaTimothyMixDeliversNYS Fair champion hay — timothy/alfalfa small squares ~40 lb (1st–3rd cut) and 4×4.5 grass-mix rounds ~500 lb, stored indoors, no chemicals (prices by phone) · pickup or delivery year round · ask for Ben · 20 min from Syracusechecked Jul 17callCall 315-430-0399
Penn Yan, NY · ~78 mi~78 miAlfalfa"Approximately 100 large round bales of old second cutting alfalfa and 20 large square bales of grass hay. Asking $120/ton or about $50 per bale if they weigh at least 800#." Priced by the ton, so the per-bale figure is the seller’s own conditional estimate rather than a set price — call for a bale price.checked Aug 30callView listing ↗
La Fayette, NY · ~30 mi~30 miSmall square"We sell bundles of 21 small bales." "Whether you’re in need of a few bundles or an entire tractor trailer load, we are here to meet your needs." Orders by phone — "contact Tim today at 315-569-3824." The farm site publishes no price.checked Aug 12callCall 315-569-3824
Horseheads, NY · ~80 mi~80 miSmall square"We grow some row crops for resale, and harvest small square bales of hay which are sold locally." A beef farm that sells hay locally; the site publishes no hay price and lists email as the contact. The phone is the one filed with the NYS Farm Directory.checked Aug 12callCall 607-739-5869
Hudson, NY · ~100 mi~100 miSmall square50 lbMix"No Spray Hay - Small Square Bales approximately 50 lbs/each. 2nd cut clover and grass mix." The farm store lists it at "Sale price $10.00" but the product currently reads "Sold out", so call for what is available. "PICK UP ONLY. NOT AVAILABLE FOR DELIVERY."checked Aug 12callCall 518-851-2000
~78 mi~78 miRound4×42026 second cutting 4x4 round bales; the ad prices by the ton — it states "$250/ton" and gives no per-bale price. Will load on farm, cash sales onlychecked Sep 6callView listing ↗
Price moves in New York: 7 in the last 8 weeks
- Willow View Hill Farm · Stamford, NY$9 → $10Sep 5
- Big Creek Farm · Fort Ann, NY$50 → $55Sep 5
- Private seller$3 → $6Sep 5
- Private seller$3 → $4Sep 5
- Private seller$5 → $4Sep 5
- Private seller$6 → $7Sep 5
- Private seller$10 → $35Jul 18
Same listing, different price between our checks; nothing else counts as a move.
What hay costs in New York
BaleWise tracks 59 hay listings in New York, 51 with listed prices, checked September 6, 2026. Every price is the seller’s own, per bale, next to the size of bale it buys. Nothing is converted, estimated, or averaged into a number the seller never quoted.
4×5-and-under rounds run $14.00 to $60.00 a bale across prices from 10 sellers, with a midpoint of $45.00.
Verdicts on the board above compare a listing against other Mid-Atlantic listings of the same bale size, at least 6 of them, or we don’t rate it at all. It is the same yardstick the region board uses, so a listing carries the same verdict on either page.
This board shows New York only. Buying near a state line? The full Mid-Atlantic board includes sellers just over it.