Covering New Jersey. Search any ZIP for true distances from you.
Type
Cut
Form
Size
Delivery
Pennington, NJ · ~5 mi~5 miSmall squareGrassDeliverslocal timothy/orchard bale, the store describes it as "Bale of orchard grass/timothy hay" · shown in stock in the online store Sep 16 · curbside pickup + local deliverychecked Oct 25$12.99/bale
Flemington, NJ · ~18 mi~18 miGrassMix1st cutDeliversbale type not stated · 1st cut timothy/orchard grass mix · same farm’s 2nd cut orchard grass runs $6/bale · delivers within ~10 mi for a small charge · Hunterdon County · call 732-735-6109checked Oct 25$5.00/bale
~42 mi~42 miStrawlarge bales of wheat straw, form not stated · roadside self service on Winslow Road between Malaga Rd and Lebanon Ave, cash only. Bedding straw, not feed haychecked Oct 25$10.00/bale
Newfield, NJ · ~52 mi~52 miTimothyDeliverstimothy grass hay sold per bale, twine-tied · the store copy gives "Approximate weight: 50 lb per bale (varies by harvest)" · pick up at the store or schedule local delivery within their service area · 1200 Harding Hwy · (856) 697-4444checked Oct 25$12.00/bale
~60 mi~60 miSmall square2nd cutsquare · second cut small square hay bales; pickup at the farm in Franklin borough; the same ad also sells mulch hay at $6 a balechecked Oct 25$8.00/bale
~8 mi~8 miRoundOrchardMixround · orchard grass mix hay in large round bales, livestock quality; non certified organic, no pesticides, herbicides or synthetic fertilizer applied in over 5 years; price includes loading on your flat trailer or full size pickup; 3 bale minimumchecked Oct 25$75.00/bale
~68 mi~68 miSmall squareOrchard2nd cutsquare · 2nd cutting orchard grass in square bales, about 130 bales leftchecked Oct 25$9.00/bale
No sellers on the board within yet. BaleWise covers New Jersey and adds sellers every sweep. Try a wider distance, or check back after the next update.
Nothing on the board matches those filters.
to see all sellers, or try a wider distance.
Call for price
Sellers who publish everything but the number. Their phone or listing is one tap away.
Somerset, NJ · ~21 mi~21 miSmall squareOrchardTimothy1st + 2nd cut NJ timothy, orchard grass and brome — 45 lb bales, year round (prices by phone) · open Sat–Sun 8–5 or by appointment · ask for Ryckchecked Oct 25callCall 732-991-2473
Allentown, NJ · ~11 mi~11 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyTimothy, orchard grass + alfalfa small squares, ~50 lb stated, year round (prices by phone) · open 7 days · family farm between I-195 and Turnpike exit 7Achecked Oct 25callCall 732-598-8811
Chesterfield, NJ · ~10 mi~10 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyMixDeliversHay dealer — NJ timothy, orchard and alfalfa mixes plus trucked-in western hay, straw, shavings (prices by phone) · delivers locally and nationwide · pickup in Chesterfieldchecked Oct 25callCall 609-968-0668
Newton, NJ · ~55 mi~55 miSmall squareHay + straw at the farm feed store (prices by phone) · open 7 days · serving Sussex County since 1969 · Sussex County's first row on the boardchecked Oct 25callCall 973-383-3592
Old Bridge, NJ · ~23 mi~23 miSmall squareAlfalfaTimothyMixDeliversHay + straw dealer — feed hay is timothy-grass mix, alfalfa and brome; mulch/construction bales are the main trade, so say feed hay when you call (prices by phone) · delivers NJ, NYC, PA and beyond · pickup at the farm · Middlesex Countychecked Oct 18callCall 732-208-7767
No recorded price changes in New Jersey in the last 8 weeks.
What hay costs in New Jersey
BaleWise tracks 12 hay listings in New Jersey, 7 with listed prices, checked October 25, 2026. Every price is the seller’s own, per bale, next to the size of bale it buys. Nothing is converted, estimated, or averaged into a number the seller never quoted.
Across prices from 6 sellers the asking price runs $5.00 to $75.00 a bale. No single bale size has prices from 6 sellers behind it here yet, so that range mixes sizes. Use the Size filter on the board to compare like with like.
Verdicts on the board above compare a listing against other Mid-Atlantic listings of the same bale size, at least 6 of them, or we don’t rate it at all. It is the same yardstick the region board uses, so a listing carries the same verdict on either page.
This board shows New Jersey only. Buying near a state line? The full Mid-Atlantic board includes sellers just over it.
