Hay prices in New Jersey

Name: Hay prices in New Jersey
Creator: BaleWise

10 listings · updated September 6, 2026

Flemington, NJ · ~20 mi~20 miGrassMix1st cutDeliversbale type not stated · 1st cut timothy/orchard grass mix · same farm’s 2nd cut orchard grass runs $6/bale · delivers within ~10 mi for a small charge · Hunterdon County · call 732-735-6109checked Aug 30$5.00/bale

~22 mi~22 miRound500 lbround, weighing about 500 lb as stated · large round bales for horses, cattle and livestock; 5 bales left, $200 for all · buyer must pick upchecked Sep 6$50.00/baleFair price

~38 mi~38 mi50 lbbale not listed, bales weigh about 50 lb as stated · about 100 bales cut and baled in June 2026, dry and stored inside; the seller says it suits goats and cowschecked Sep 6$6.00/bale

Deerfield Street, NJ · ~59 mi~59 miRound4×5Mix4×5 round, weight not stated · mixed grass hay the seller describes as good quality horse haychecked Sep 6$80.00/balePriced high

Call for price

Sellers who publish everything but the number. Their phone or listing is one tap away.

Somerset, NJ · ~19 mi~19 miSmall squareOrchardTimothy1st + 2nd cut NJ timothy, orchard grass and brome — 45 lb bales, year round (prices by phone) · open Sat–Sun 8–5 or by appointment · ask for Ryckchecked Jul 17callCall 732-991-2473

Allentown, NJ · ~8 mi~8 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyTimothy, orchard grass + alfalfa small squares, ~50 lb stated, year round (prices by phone) · open 7 days · family farm between I-195 and Turnpike exit 7Achecked Jul 17callCall 732-598-8811

Chesterfield, NJ · ~9 mi~9 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardTimothyMixDeliversHay dealer — NJ timothy, orchard and alfalfa mixes plus trucked-in western hay, straw, shavings (prices by phone) · delivers locally and nationwide · pickup in Chesterfieldchecked Aug 30callCall 609-968-0668

Newton, NJ · ~55 mi~55 miSmall squareHay + straw at the farm feed store (prices by phone) · open 7 days · serving Sussex County since 1969 · Sussex County's first row on the boardchecked Jul 17callCall 973-383-3592

Pennington, NJ · ~7 mi~7 miSmall squareOrchardTimothyDeliversFeed store — local timothy/orchard bales carried in the online store, stock varies (price shown at checkout / by phone) · out of stock at the Jul 17 check, not discontinued — call before the trip · curbside pickup + local deliverychecked Jul 17callSold out

Old Bridge, NJ · ~20 mi~20 miSmall squareAlfalfaTimothyMixDeliversHay + straw dealer — feed hay is timothy-grass mix, alfalfa and brome; mulch/construction bales are the main trade, so say feed hay when you call (prices by phone) · delivers NJ, NYC, PA and beyond · pickup at the farm · Middlesex Countychecked Aug 30callCall 732-208-7767

Selling hay? Listing is free. Buyers here are already looking.List your hay ›

No recorded price changes in New Jersey in the last 8 weeks.

What hay costs in New Jersey

BaleWise tracks 10 hay listings in New Jersey, 4 with listed prices, checked September 6, 2026. Every price is the seller’s own, per bale, next to the size of bale it buys. Nothing is converted, estimated, or averaged into a number the seller never quoted.

That is too few for us to quote a price range from. Below prices from 6 sellers we would just be describing a handful of farms. Every one of them is on the board above.

Verdicts on the board above compare a listing against other Mid-Atlantic listings of the same bale size, at least 6 of them, or we don’t rate it at all. It is the same yardstick the region board uses, so a listing carries the same verdict on either page.

This board shows New Jersey only. Buying near a state line? The full Mid-Atlantic board includes sellers just over it.