Hay prices in Indiana
Covering Indiana. Search any ZIP for true distances from you.
Type
Cut
Form
Size
Delivery
~99 mi~99 miSmall square50 lb1st cutsquare · 2026 first cutting grass hay small squares at a stated 50 lb, baled at 15% moisture, no rain, stored insidechecked Sep 9$6.00/baleFair price
~54 mi~54 miRound4×5AlfalfaOrchardTimothyMix1st cutround · 2026 first cutting mixed hay (orchard grass, clovers, alfalfa-timothy), 4x5 round bales, tight and baled dry with a new baler; seller can help load, cash onlychecked Sep 9$55.00/balePriced high
Kewanna, IN · ~52 mi~52 miSmall squareAlfalfaDeliversPure alfalfa small squares with no weeds, good moisture and no rain, stored inside — $10 a bale, dropping to $9 at 50 or more. Pickup preferred, delivery available for a fee. The same seller lists 4x5 alfalfa rounds and wheat strawchecked Sep 9$10.00/bale
Kewanna, IN · ~52 mi~52 miRound4×5AlfalfaDeliversPure alfalfa 4x5 round bales with no weeds, good moisture and no rain, stored inside, at $80 a bale. Pickup preferred, delivery available for a feechecked Sep 9$80.00/balePriced high
~86 mi~86 miSmall squareAlfalfa1st cutDeliverssquare · small squares of alfalfa/grass hay, 1st cutting $7.00, 2nd and 3rd cutting $8.00; 100-bale minimum, pick up in Wakarusa or Rochesterchecked Sep 2$7.00/bale
~50 mi~50 miRound4×51st cutround · 4x5 grass rounds, first cutting baled 7/2/26, 30 bales, prefers to sell all together; seller can help loadchecked Sep 9$40.00/baleGood deal
~49 mi~49 miRound4×4round · 4x4 net-wrapped rounds, 2026 crop, 150 bales, baled dry with no rain and barn-stored the same daychecked Sep 9$50.00/baleFair price
~79 mi~79 miAlfalfaOrchardMix3rd cutting alfalfa/orchard grass 80/20 mix, baled dry 7/29, sold off the wagon before it is unloaded; the seller also lists 1st cutting at $6.00 and 2nd at $6.50; bale form not statedchecked Sep 9$6.50/bale
~71 mi~71 miSmall squareAlfalfaTimothy1st cut2026 alfalfa/timothy small square bales, first cutting; the seller prices second and later cuttings at $8 a bale; located west of Decaturchecked Sep 9$7.00/bale
~59 mi~59 miRound4×4Grass4×4 grass hay round bales, never been rained on; the seller states 550 lb baleschecked Sep 9$60.00/balePriced high
~59 mi~59 miSmall square65 lbGrassGrass hay squares, never been rained on; the seller states 65 lb baleschecked Sep 9$5.00/baleGood deal
~87 mi~87 miSmall squareGrass1st cutDelivers1st cutting grass hay made 6/20/26; the seller states 32-inch bales at roughly 35–40 lb; delivery availablechecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~30 mi~30 miGrass1st cut1st cutting grass hay, south Anderson near Hoosier Park; the seller can help load; bale form not statedchecked Sep 9$4.00/bale
~32 mi~32 miSmall squareGrassMixDelivers2026 pasture mix small bales, both 1st and 2nd cutting offered at this price; delivery availablechecked Sep 9$8.00/bale
~32 mi~32 miRound800 lbGrassMixDeliversPasture mix round bales, barn kept; the seller states 800 lb bales; delivery availablechecked Sep 9$55.00/balePriced high
~70 mi~70 miSmall squareAlfalfa2nd cut2nd cutting pure alfalfa squares, horse quality, no rain. The seller notes Craigslist would not accept $5.50 in its price box, so the listed tag reads $5checked Sep 9$5.50/bale
~26 mi~26 miRound4×5Grass1st cut2026 first cutting grass and clover, 4×5 net wrap, put up dry and mostly stored outside; the seller says they weigh about 700 lb, which is a hedged figure rather than a stated weight; volume discount offeredchecked Sep 9$50.00/baleFair price
~11 mi~11 miLarge square3×4×8AlfalfaDelivers3x4x8 alfalfa horse hay sprayed with preservative, stored inside on pallets; delivery offered. The ad prints a 936 area-code number, which is Texas rather than localchecked Sep 9$95.00/balePriced high
~79 mi~79 miSmall squareGrassMixMixed orchard, fescue and timothy squares currently in the barn, 417 available; $5 a bale if you take 20 or more. The seller states it was lightly rained on, then tedded and dried an extra day before baling. Pickup and cash only; located between Patricksburg and Bowling Greenchecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~103 mi~103 miRoundGrass1st cut1st cutting grass round bales cut in late July 2026; the seller can help loadchecked Sep 9$45.00/bale
~112 mi~112 miRound4×5GrassFescue 4×5 round bales, net wrappedchecked Sep 9$25.00/baleGood deal
~16 mi~16 miRound4×5AlfalfaOrchardTimothy1st cutround · 2026 first cutting alfalfa, orchard grass and timothy with some weeds, which the seller calls great cow hay and not good horse quality. Baled very dry and tight, net wrapped, in 4′x5′ rounds the seller describes as 900-1,000 lb. Over 100 availablechecked Sep 9$25.00/baleGood deal
~46 mi~46 miAlfalfaThird cutting alfalfa with no rain and no weeds at $7.50 a bale, dropping to $7.00 if you take 150 or more. The ad never says what size bale it ischecked Sep 9$7.50/bale
~59 mi~59 miSmall squareGrass1st cutsquare · first cutting grass hay in small squares at $4. The same seller lists first cutting alfalfa and orchard grass at $5.50 and second cutting alfalfa and orchard grass at $6, with a 20-bale minimum; all of it made dry and never rained onchecked Sep 9$4.00/bale
~58 mi~58 miAlfalfa1st cut2026 first cutting alfalfa, give or take 200 bales left, which the seller calls good tight bales made right. The seller will help load and asks buyers to inquire about delivery. The ad never says what size bale it ischecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~53 mi~53 miRound4×4round · 150 net-wrapped 4x4 rounds of 2026 hay, baled dry with no rain and put in the barn the same day; located about 10 miles west of Rushville and 5 miles east of Morristown. The seller will load your truck or trailerchecked Sep 9$50.00/baleFair price
~87 mi~87 miAlfalfa1st cutDeliversPure alfalfa wet-wrap baleage baled 5/28/2026 at 40% moisture; delivery availablechecked Sep 9$125/bale
~53 mi~53 miRound4×4round · 150 net-wrapped 4x4 rounds of 2026 hay which the seller says were baled dry with no rain and put in the barn the same day. No cutting or weight is statedchecked Sep 9$50.00/baleFair price
~103 mi~103 miRoundGrassMix1st cutround · first-cutting mixed grass round bales; the seller stresses this is genuinely first cutting, delayed by a wet spring and summer. No bale size or weight is statedchecked Sep 9$45.00/bale
~99 mi~99 miSmall squareGrass1st cutsquare · first-cutting small square grass hay the seller says was baled right, stored inside and never rained on. No bale size or weight is statedchecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~94 mi~94 midetails in notesthird-cutting hay baled 25 August 2026 which the seller says never got rained on, 70 bales available, cash, pickup at Valparaiso. The ad never says what size bale it ischecked Sep 9$7.00/bale
~41 mi~41 miSmall squareGrass2nd cutsquare · 2nd cutting grass/clover hay – small square bales 2nd cutting baled on 8/25/26 Never rained on Baled dry Barn stored Mostly clover and orchardgrass Good leafy livestock hay Great for goats, sheep, cattle and other livestock Approximately 100+ bales available Small square bales $6 per balechecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~61 mi~61 miAlfalfaMixOrganic alfalfa hay $7/bale Organic alfalfa/clover/grass mix $6/bale Organic alfalfa/clover/grass mix with some Foxtail $5/balechecked Sep 9$7.00/bale
~97 mi~97 miRoundGrassround · Hay Round Bales 3rd Cutting 2026 Clean Grass Hay. Twine Baled 08/29/26. $40 Guilford, IN 8 2 0 0checked Sep 9$40.00/bale
~105 mi~105 miRoundAlfalfaround · 2nd cutting = $100 / 24 bales 3rd cutting = $80 /10 bales Will make a deal if taking more than 10 Perfect for horses, cattle, goats, and other livestock. 📍Michigan City, Indiana 🚜 We can help load, but please contact us ahead of time so we can arrange to be available. Bring your trailer.checked Sep 9$80.00/bale
~99 mi~99 miGrassHay has some clover Great for cattle,goats,horses Bring trailer will load Cash only!!!!checked Sep 9$35.00/bale
~44 mi~44 miAlfalfaOrchardMixMixed hay. Alfalfa clover and orchard grass. Baled in July. thanks.checked Sep 9$30.00/bale
~90 mi~90 miRound4×5GrassMixround · Mixed grass hay, 4 x 5 size, string. Good quality, Fall 2025.checked Sep 9$20.00/baleGood deal
~168 mi~168 miSmall square40 lbGrassMix1st cutsquare · 2026 first-cut mixed grass hay — clover, orchard, timothy and alfalfa — stored inside, and the seller says no Roundup is used on the fields. $6 a bale on a 10-bale minimum. Small square bales at a stated weight of roughly 40 lb, which the ad gives as 14x18 by around 36-38 inches long. Pickup in Boonville, cash only, no deliverychecked Sep 9$6.00/baleFair price
~107 mi~107 miStrawClean wheat straw in what the seller calls tight bales, $4.00 a bale at Hamilton Indiana. Bedding straw, not feed hay; the ad states no bale formchecked Sep 9$4.00/bale
~87 mi~87 miSmall squareGrasssquare · 200 bales of third-cutting grass hay in small squares, which the seller says was made dry with no weeds. $6.50 per bale if you take them all; cash onlychecked Sep 9$6.50/bale
~150 mi~150 miSmall squareGrassMix2nd cutsquare · second-cutting mixed grass field hay in square bales, 200+ available at $3 per bale. The seller describes them as 45-50 lb bales and says they have more than they needchecked Sep 9$3.00/bale
~7 mi~7 miSmall squareGrasssquare · 2026 third-cutting hay of clover, alfalfa and grass in small squares which the seller calls good quality, 200 bales available on 281st Street near US 31. The listing states no price in its textchecked Sep 9$6.00/bale
~94 mi~94 miSmall squareAlfalfa1st cutsquare · first-cutting square hay at $4 a bale with second cutting at $5, around 4,500 bales available. The seller writes that with all the rain this year they have too much haychecked Sep 9$4.00/bale
✓ VerifiedNorth Salem, IN · ~42 mi~42 miSmall square2-stringStrawDelivers2026 Straw bales for sale. Straw was baled 7/7/26. I have several hundred available. $6 per bale. Delivery and stacking is available for an additional charge.listed Sep 11$6.00/bale
Call for price
Sellers who publish everything but the number. Their phone or listing is one tap away.
Russiaville, IN · ~12 mi~12 miSmall squareAlfalfaOrchardMixDeliversAlfalfa/orchard-grass mix horse hay — small squares as singles or 21-bale bundles, plus net-wrapped 4x5 rounds and weed-free straw; delivery up to semi loads (798 small bales) — text Matt for a quotechecked Sep 9callCall 765-513-0156
La Porte, IN · ~96 mi~96 midetails in notesA northwest Indiana family farm that states it raises and sells hay alongside beef cattle, freezer pork, maple syrup and straw (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 574-323-3506
North Salem, IN · ~42 mi~42 midetails in notesA family-owned farm that states it raises crops, hay and freezer beef (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 317-627-7251
Jonesboro, IN · ~28 mi~28 midetails in notesA family farm that states it is focused on raising quality beef and hay (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 765-618-3055
Silver Lake, IN · ~53 mi~53 miRoundGrassMixGrass/alfalfa mix hay, available while supply lasts; the farm's Farmer's Exchange classified on the same phone lists big round bales and big square bales of alfalfa-grass and grass, and beef cow hay. The farm says to contact it for the latest priceschecked Aug 5callCall 574-268-7306
Cloverdale, IN · ~65 mi~65 miRoundFarms 400+ acres of corn, soybeans and hay, and states it offers round bales of hay seasonally (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 317-509-1508
Birdseye, IN · ~142 mi~142 midetails in notesA small family operation raising Angus beef cattle, hay and straw; states it grows clover and lespedeza for hay as well as for seed (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 812-326-2709
Converse, IN · ~24 mi~24 miGrassA husband-and-wife farm store that lists grass hay among its homegrown products alongside raw milk, eggs and baked goods — likely small volume (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 765-618-8125
Plymouth, IN · ~74 mi~74 midetails in notesA small family farm that states it sells honey, hay, seasonal produce and eggs alongside its flower field and u-pick (prices by phone)checked Aug 5callCall 574-952-8909
North Manchester, IN · ~51 mi~51 miAlfalfaOrchardTimothyDeliversStates a quarter century of hay production and lists alfalfa, alfalfa/orchardgrass, timothy/alfalfa and timothy; bales are palletized and net-wrapped and delivered on company trucks. Note the farm describes itself as producing, buying and marketing hay, so it trades as a dealer as well as a grower (prices by phone)checked Sep 9callCall 260-568-1585
~67 mi~67 miRound4×5AlfalfaOrganic first, second and third cutting alfalfa/grass hay in 4x5 bales, run through a rotor-cut baler for mixing in a TMR mixer, not rained on and barn stored on skids, roughly 600 bales left (price by phone)checked Sep 9callView listing ↗
Price moves in Indiana: 4 in the last 8 weeks
- Ryan Troutman · Kewanna, IN$9 → $10Sep 8
- Private seller$65 → $55Aug 25
- Private seller$60 → $50Aug 25
- Private seller$73 → $60Aug 11
Same listing, different price between our checks; nothing else counts as a move.
What hay costs in Indiana
BaleWise tracks 56 hay listings in Indiana, 45 with listed prices, checked September 11, 2026. Every price is the seller’s own, per bale, next to the size of bale it buys. Nothing is converted, estimated, or averaged into a number the seller never quoted.
4×5-and-under rounds run $20.00 to $80.00 a bale across prices from 12 sellers, with a midpoint of $50.00.
Verdicts on the board above compare a listing against other Midwest listings of the same bale size, at least 6 of them, or we don’t rate it at all. It is the same yardstick the region board uses, so a listing carries the same verdict on either page.
This board shows Indiana only. Buying near a state line? The full Midwest board includes sellers just over it.